Last updated:
🧑⚖️ Face recognition wrongful arrests: the known US cases
At least 16 people in the US have been wrongly arrested after a police face recognition match. Here is each case: the charge, the time held, what went wrong and the outcome.
On this page 9 sections
Police face recognition has led to at least 16 publicly reported wrongful arrests in the United States. This file lists each one, with its source.
The ACLU counted 14 cases in April 2026. We add two more: one from a newspaper investigation and one from a court ruling in November 2026.
Who has been wrongly arrested after a face recognition match?
| Year | Person | Arrested by or where | Accused of | Time held | What went wrong | Outcome | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Nijeer Parks | Woodbridge, New Jersey police | Theft and assault on an officer | 10 days | Police did not wait for DNA and fingerprint results. | Charges dropped. $300,000 settlement. | New Jersey Law Journal (10 Sep 2024) |
| 2019 | Michael Oliver | Detroit police | Snatching a phone | More than two days | The match came from a distorted still image. His arm tattoos did not match. | Settled for $110,000 in 2024. | Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse (read 14 Nov 2026) |
| 2020 | Robert Williams | Detroit police | Shoplifting | Not stated | The ACLU sued in 2021. | Detroit paid $300,000 and stopped arrests based only on a match or a match-built lineup. | AP via CBS Detroit (4 Sep 2025) |
| 2021 | Christopher Gatlin | St. Louis police | Assault on a MetroLink train | 17 months | The victim first picked other men. An officer told him to keep looking. | Case dismissed after body-camera video surfaced. Lawsuit filed. | KTVI via Yahoo News (5 Feb 2025) |
| 2021 | Kimberlee Williams | Detained in Lawton, Oklahoma, on Maryland warrants | Bank fraud in Maryland | Six months | Police did not check her Oklahoma alibi. The warrant application did not mention face recognition. | Charges dropped in December 2021. | ACLU (17 Apr 2026) |
| 2022 | Alonzo Sawyer | Maryland transit police | Assault | Not stated | His wife provided evidence that cleared him. | Cleared. | Washington Post, as summarised by the AI Incident Database (13 Jan 2025) |
| 2022 | Randal Quran Reid | Arrested near Atlanta on a Jefferson Parish, Louisiana, warrant | Not stated | Six days | The match was the only basis for naming him. | $200,000 settlement in May 2025. | Biometric Update (18 Jun 2025) |
| 2023 | Porcha Woodruff | Detroit police | Carjacking | About 10 hours | She was eight months pregnant. The victim picked her from a lineup built on the match. | Charges dropped. A judge dismissed her lawsuit in August 2025; an appeal was planned. | AP via CBS Detroit (4 Sep 2025) |
| 2023 | Jason Killinger | Reno police, after a casino's face recognition alert | Not stated | Not stated | A casino's face recognition system flagged him. | The casino settled. A ruling on the city's liability was pending in October 2026. | Biometric Update (14 Oct 2026) |
| 2024 | Robert Dillon | Jacksonville Beach, Florida, police | Attempting to lure a child | One night | He lived 300 miles away. A plate-reader search found no trace of his car. | Charges dropped. He sued in June 2026. | ACLU of Florida (10 Jun 2026) |
| 2024 | Javier Lorenzano Nunez | Arrested in Mexico for Phoenix police | A 1998 murder | Nearly a year | An old photo of the named suspect returned 250 possible matches. | Charges dismissed after DNA and fingerprints excluded him. Federal lawsuit filed. | ABC15 Arizona (read 14 Nov 2026) |
| 2024 | Jason Vernau | Miami police | Check fraud | Three days | Named in a Washington Post investigation of eight cases. | Charges dropped. | Washington Post, as summarised by the AI Incident Database (13 Jan 2025) |
| 2025 | Trevis Williams | New York police | Indecent exposure | Two days | He was eight inches taller and 70 pounds heavier than the suspect. Phone data put him miles away. | Case dismissed in July 2025. | ABC7 New York (27 Aug 2025) |
| 2025 | Angela Lipps | US Marshals in Tennessee, on a Fargo, North Dakota, warrant | Bank fraud | About five months | Bank records showed she was in Tennessee. | Charges dismissed on 24 December 2025. She sued for $10 million in September 2026. | WOWT (17 Sep 2026) |
| 2025 | Beau Burgess | Orlando police | Not stated | Not stated | Arrested in August 2025 after a database search. | Both cases dropped. | WESH (18 Feb 2026) |
| 2024 or 2025 (reports differ) | Osorio (plaintiff in Osorio v. Kilmer) | Florence, Kentucky, police | Check fraud | More than two weeks | He was working in Nebraska. | Indictment dismissed in May 2025. A judge let his lawsuit proceed in November 2026. | ID Tech (11 Nov 2026) |
Download the dataset (CSV)JSON
16 rows, compiled 14 Nov 2026. Free to reuse with credit (CC BY 4.0). Each row names its source.
Every person listed was cleared, or had the charges dropped or dismissed, according to the source cited. “Not stated” means our source did not say.
What did the arrests cost people?
Time in custody ranged from about 10 hours to 17 months, in the 12 cases where a source states it.
Christopher Gatlin spent 17 months in a St. Louis jail before body-camera video undid the identification KTVI via Yahoo News (5 Feb 2025).
Javier Lorenzano Nunez was held for nearly a year, in Mexico and then Arizona, over a 1998 murder ABC15 Arizona (read 14 Nov 2026).
Angela Lipps was jailed for about five months on a $100,000 bond. Prosecutors dismissed all eight charges on 24 December 2025 WOWT (17 Sep 2026).
Even one night has a price. Robert Dillon pledged his truck’s title to post bond, and his mugshot stayed online ACLU of Florida (10 Jun 2026).
What do the cases have in common?
- A match was treated as an identification. In Randal Reid’s case the match was the only basis for naming him.
- A lineup was built on the match. Victims then picked the look-alike, as in the Woodruff and Gatlin cases.
- Alibi evidence existed. Bank records, phone location data and work records placed people elsewhere.
- Obvious differences were missed. Trevis Williams was eight inches taller than the suspect. Michael Oliver’s tattoos did not match.
- Warrants crossed state lines. Four people were arrested far from the crime scene, in another state or country.
- Other tools were ignored. A plate-reader search found no trace of Robert Dillon’s car. The court was not told, his lawsuit says.
The alert can also start outside the police. In Reno, a casino’s system flagged Jason Killinger Biometric Update (14 Oct 2026).
A former casino security officer said up to half of its alerts were false. A director put the figure near 10%, the same report says.
Which systems were used?
Most reports do not name the software. Where they do, the tools differ.
- Clearview AI. Named in the Reid case Biometric Update (18 Jun 2025). One report also names it in the Lipps case State of Surveillance (read 14 Nov 2026).
- Florida’s statewide system. The Pinellas County Sheriff runs it. It appears in two of the Florida cases.
- Government photo databases. Arizona investigators searched state police and FBI databases with a decades-old photo.
- A private system. A casino’s own cameras produced the Reno alert.
What have cities paid?
Four settlements are on the record in our sources. They total $910,000.
- Nijeer Parks: $300,000 New Jersey Law Journal (10 Sep 2024).
- Robert Williams: $300,000 from Detroit AP via CBS Detroit (4 Sep 2025).
- Randal Reid: $200,000 from the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office, which admitted no fault.
- Michael Oliver: $110,000 Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse (read 14 Nov 2026).
Not every suit succeeds. A federal judge dismissed Porcha Woodruff’s case in August 2025 and still called her arrest troubling.
Angela Lipps is seeking $10 million from Fargo and one of its detectives. Those claims have not been tested in court.
Why is the true number unknown?
Only cases that reach a lawsuit or a newsroom get counted. Police do not always tell defendants that face recognition produced the lead.
Counts differ between trackers for the same reason. In February 2026 a Florida researcher called the Orlando case the eleventh known WESH (18 Feb 2026).
Two months later the ACLU listed fourteen ACLU (17 Apr 2026).
What is the newest case?
In November 2026 a federal judge in Kentucky refused to dismiss Osorio v. Kilmer. The judge denied the detective qualified immunity at this stage ID Tech (11 Nov 2026).
Osorio was jailed for more than two weeks. His indictment was dismissed with prejudice on 7 May 2025 Tech Times UK (13 Nov 2026).
The two reports give different arrest dates, so the dataset marks the year as uncertain.
What rules have followed?
Detroit no longer arrests people based only on a face match, or on a lineup built from one. Indiana has enacted a similar protection, the ACLU says.
More than 20 cities and other jurisdictions have banned police use of face recognition, by the ACLU’s count.
In New York, the Legal Aid Society asked for an investigation after the Trevis Williams arrest ABC7 New York (27 Aug 2025).
What can you do if a face match leads to your arrest?
- Ask for a lawyer and say nothing else. A public defender can demand the evidence behind the arrest.
- Ask how you were identified. Your lawyer can ask in writing whether face recognition or a database search produced the lead.
- Preserve your alibi quickly. Bank records, work records, phone location history and receipts cleared several people in this file.
- Tell a civil liberties group. The ACLU tracks these cases and has sued on behalf of at least two people listed.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
How many people have been wrongly arrested because of face recognition?
At least 16 cases have been publicly reported in the United States as of 14 November 2026. The real number is unknown, because police do not always disclose when the technology is used.
Who was the first known case?
The earliest arrests in this file date from 2019: Nijeer Parks in New Jersey and Michael Oliver in Detroit. Robert Williams was arrested in Detroit in 2020.
How long were people held?
From about 10 hours to 17 months, where sources say. Christopher Gatlin spent 17 months in jail, and Javier Lorenzano Nunez nearly a year.
Is a face recognition match enough to arrest someone?
It should not be. A match is an investigative lead. After its wrongful arrests, Detroit stopped making arrests based only on a match or a lineup built from one.
Which systems were involved?
They vary. Reports name Clearview AI, Florida’s statewide sheriff-run system, government photo databases and a casino’s own system. Many reports name no software.
Have victims been compensated?
Some. Our sources record four settlements totalling $910,000. Other lawsuits are pending, and one was dismissed.
Can I reuse this list?
Yes. Download the CSV or JSON and credit Max Intel and the sources named in each row.