Last updated:
📍 Location warrants after Chatrie: what police need now
In June 2026 the Supreme Court held that taking phone location history from Google is a search. Here is what changed, what did not, and what is still undecided.
On this page 9 sections
On 29 June 2026 the US Supreme Court ruled that police ran a Fourth Amendment search when they took location history from Google.
The ruling, Chatrie v. United States, settles one question and leaves several open. This page explains both, in plain language.
What did the Supreme Court decide?
The Court held that a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy in their phone’s location information Supreme Court, Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026).
Getting that data from Google was therefore a search. The Constitution’s limits on searches apply.
Justice Kagan wrote for the Court. Six justices agreed with the result and three dissented UNC School of Government (13 Jul 2026).
The Court rejected two government arguments. One was that two hours of data is too little to matter.
The other was that users gave up their privacy by switching Location History on. The Court said Google prompts users repeatedly and explains little.
What was the case about?
A man robbed a credit union in Midlothian, Virginia, on 20 May 2019. Witnesses and video showed him appearing to talk on a phone. Police had no name.
On 14 June they obtained a geofence warrant. It ordered Google to search for phones within 150 metres of the credit union.
- Step one. Google gave anonymised data for every phone in the circle, from 30 minutes before the robbery to 30 minutes after.
- Step two. Police narrowed the list. Google added two hours of movements for those phones, inside and outside the circle.
- Step three. Police narrowed it again. Google handed over names and phone numbers.
Google identified three users in the end. One was Okello Chatrie, who was charged with the robbery.
Location History logged a phone’s position about every two minutes, the opinion says.
What did the Court leave undecided?
- Whether this warrant was valid. The Court decided only that a search took place. The case went back to the appeals court.
- Whether any geofence warrant can be valid. A warrant must be specific and rest on probable cause. The trial judge found this one plainly violated the Fourth Amendment.
- Whether the evidence stays in. The trial court had allowed it under the good-faith exception. The Supreme Court did not rule on that.
The Supreme Court’s judgment went to the Fourth Circuit at the end of July 2026. We found no ruling from that court as of 14 November.
One legal scholar expects the good-faith exception to apply, so Chatrie himself may gain nothing UNC School of Government (13 Jul 2026).
Two justices would have gone further. Justice Jackson, joined by Justice Sotomayor, would have held the three-step process unconstitutional, the same analysis reports.
Where do other location methods stand?
| Method | Status on 14 Nov 2026 | Basis | Notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Location history from a tech company, by geofence | A search under the Fourth Amendment | Chatrie v. United States (2026) | Whether any geofence warrant can be valid was left to the lower courts. A New Jersey court has since thrown out geofence evidence. | Supreme Court, Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026) |
| Cell-site records from a phone carrier | A search under the Fourth Amendment | Carpenter v. United States (2018) | Chatrie applied and extended this ruling. | Supreme Court, Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026) |
| Location data from other apps | Likely needs a valid warrant | A legal scholar's reading of Chatrie | The analysis gives a coffee chain's app as an example. | UNC School of Government (13 Jul 2026) |
| Tower dumps (everyone near a cell tower) | Ruled unconstitutional by one federal judge; on appeal | In re Four Applications (S.D. Miss., 5 Aug 2026) | Not decided by the Supreme Court. Courts were split before Chatrie. | Court Watch (5 Aug 2026) |
| Cell-site simulators (Stingrays) | A search, one federal appeals court held | Andrews v. Baltimore City Police Dep't (4th Cir., 24 Sep 2026) | The officers still received qualified immunity in the civil case. | The Federal Docket (29 Sep 2026) |
| Plate-reader database searches | Ruled a search by one federal district court | United States v. Kyle (N.D. Okla., 1 Oct 2026) | See our separate page on the Kyle ruling. | Paul, Weiss (16 Oct 2026) |
| Keyword warrants (everyone who searched a term) | Not decided by the Supreme Court | State courts split before Chatrie | Colorado's top court treated one as a search in 2023. Pennsylvania's found no privacy interest in 2025. | Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026) |
| Location data bought from data brokers | Not decided by the Supreme Court | No warrant is involved when police buy data, so Chatrie does not settle it. | EFF (29 Jun 2026) |
Download the dataset (CSV)JSON
8 rows, compiled 14 Nov 2026. Free to reuse with credit (CC BY 4.0). Each row names its source.
This is a summary of federal constitutional law, not legal advice. State law can protect more.
Plate readers are a separate fight in the lower courts. See our page on the ruling that a Flock search needed a warrant.
Police can also buy location data without any warrant. Our data broker loophole guide covers that.
How have courts applied Chatrie so far?
Lower courts moved quickly. Within four months, judges applied the ruling to tower dumps, cell-site simulators and plate readers.
| Case | Court | Date | Technology | What the court held | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chatrie v. United States | US Supreme Court | 29 Jun 2026 | Geofence warrant | Taking location history from Google is a search. Validity of the warrant left open. | Supreme Court, Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026) |
| In re Four Applications for Search Warrants | US District Court, S.D. Mississippi | 5 Aug 2026 | Tower dump | Tower dumps are unconstitutional general searches. Four FBI applications stayed denied. The government appealed. | Court Watch (5 Aug 2026) |
| Andrews v. Baltimore City Police Dep't | US Court of Appeals, 4th Circuit | 24 Sep 2026 | Cell-site simulator | Using the device was a search. Officers got qualified immunity. | The Federal Docket (29 Sep 2026) |
| United States v. Kyle | US District Court, N.D. Oklahoma | 1 Oct 2026 | Plate-reader search | Cited among early rulings applying Chatrie. See our page on the case. | Paul, Weiss (16 Oct 2026) |
| State v. Hobbs | New Jersey Appellate Division | 2 Oct 2026 | Geofence warrant | Evidence should have been suppressed. The fact that phones are common is not probable cause. | Paul, Weiss (16 Oct 2026) |
The Mississippi ruling goes furthest. Judge Carlton Reeves called tower dumps unconstitutional in every case, citing Chatrie 13 times Court Watch (5 Aug 2026).
The government has appealed that ruling to the Fifth Circuit The Federal Docket (29 Sep 2026).
The New Jersey case shows the practical test. Police said the robbers probably carried phones, because nearly everyone does.
The appeals court said that is a hunch, not probable cause. Otherwise police could seek a geofence warrant in almost any case Paul, Weiss (16 Oct 2026).
What had courts said before Chatrie?
These earlier rulings show how divided courts were, especially on keyword warrants and tower dumps Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026).
| Case | Court | Date | Technology | What the court held | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| State v. Bryant | New Jersey Appellate Division | 4 Dec 2025 | Tower dump | Tower dumps can be lawful, with a specific warrant and probable cause. | Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026) |
| Commonwealth v. Kurtz | Pennsylvania Supreme Court | 16 Dec 2025 | Keyword warrant | No reasonable expectation of privacy in the search records at issue. | Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026) |
| People v. Seymour | Colorado Supreme Court | 2023 | Keyword warrant | A search under the state constitution, but not unconstitutional in every case. | Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026) |
| United States v. Medina | US District Court, Rhode Island | 2024 | Tower dump | A warrant is required. Evidence was kept under the good-faith exception. | Congressional Research Service (15 Sep 2026) |
| Carpenter v. United States | US Supreme Court | 2018 | Cell-site records | Getting a person's cell-site location records is a search. | Supreme Court, Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026) |
Download the dataset (CSV)JSON
10 rows, compiled 14 Nov 2026. Free to reuse with credit (CC BY 4.0). Each row names its source.
Google reportedly handles about 400 keyword warrants a year, the same report says.
Do any state laws go further?
Utah does. Since 2025 its law has required a warrant for geofence data and has restricted keyword warrants, the Congressional Research Service reports.
Bills to limit these warrants were introduced in New York, Missouri, Delaware and California. The report does not list them as enacted.
State constitutions can also protect more than the federal one. Colorado’s court relied on its own constitution in 2023.
Do geofence warrants to Google still work?
Mostly not. Google announced storage changes in 2023 that eventually ended its ability to answer them EFF (29 Jun 2026).
EFF says mass geofence searches of Google users have not been possible since July 2025. The dissent made the same point, one analysis notes UNC School of Government (13 Jul 2026).
The ruling still matters. EFF expects its reasoning to reach location data held by other apps and companies.
What does this mean for your phone?
- A warrant is now the baseline. Police need to justify a search before taking location history from a company.
- Collection has not stopped. Apps, carriers and ad networks still log where your phone goes.
- Cut what exists. Turn off location history, limit app location access and reset your advertising ID.
- Check for tracking. Our phone tracking check walks through the settings.
Frequently asked questions
What is a geofence warrant?
It orders a company to find every device inside a set area during a set time. Police use it when they know where a crime happened and not who did it.
Did the Supreme Court ban geofence warrants?
No. In June 2026 it held that taking location history is a search. It left the validity of geofence warrants to the lower courts.
Do police need a warrant for my location history now?
Generally yes, when they take it from a company. Exceptions to the warrant rule still exist, and buying data from brokers was not decided.
Has any court thrown out geofence evidence since Chatrie?
Yes. On 2 October 2026 a New Jersey appeals court ruled on a robbery case. It held the geofence evidence should have been suppressed for lack of probable cause.
What happened to Okello Chatrie’s case?
It went back to the appeals court. That court must decide whether the warrant was valid and whether the evidence can still be used.
Does the ruling cover tower dumps and keyword warrants?
Not directly. The Supreme Court did not decide them. In August 2026 a federal judge in Mississippi relied on Chatrie to rule tower dumps unconstitutional. That ruling is on appeal.