Last updated:
🏷️ Surveillance pricing bans: New York City, New York State and beyond
Prices set from your personal data are being banned in more places. What New York City passed, how the state laws compare, and how to check a price.
On this page 6 sections
Two shoppers can see two prices for the same item. When the difference comes from personal data, it is called surveillance pricing.
In 2026 several states and two cities moved to ban it. New York City passed its ban on 12 November.
What is surveillance pricing?
New York City defines it as “pricing set completely or in part by algorithm that uses personal data” to charge customers different prices New York City Council (12 Nov 2026).
Gothamist lists the inputs as demographics, credit, browsing history or purchase history Gothamist (12 Nov 2026).
One example the Council cited: a 55-inch TV cost $499 on the Target app inside a store, and $599 in the car park.
Uber, Lyft, Target, Instacart and airlines have faced scrutiny over the practice. Many of them deny using it Gothamist (12 Nov 2026).
What does New York City’s ban do?
- The bill is Introduction 891-A, sponsored by Speaker Julie Menin New York City Council (12 Nov 2026).
- It covers prices online and in stores, though the practice is mainly online Gothamist (12 Nov 2026).
- The city can fine up to $1,000 for each transaction that breaks the ban.
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he supports it. Menin said discounts are not affected.
- Uber warned it would hurt small restaurants that use targeted discounts on Uber Eats.
Which other places have acted?
| Place | Law | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | Intro 891-A: broad ban, fines up to $1,000 per transaction | Passed 12 Nov 2026 | Gothamist (12 Nov 2026) |
| New York State | One Fair Price Act (S.8623-B): broad ban, enforced by the Attorney General | Passed June 2026; awaiting the governor as of late October | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
| Maryland | Protection from Predatory Pricing Act (HB 895): food retailers and delivery apps | Signed 28 Apr 2026; in force 1 Oct 2026 | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
| Connecticut | Public Act 26-130: retail sellers and food delivery; disclosure rule for others | Signed 2026; pricing rules from 1 Jul 2027 | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
| New Jersey | Fair Price Protection Act, with a private right to sue | Signed 23 Jul 2026; in force 1 Aug 2027 | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
| Seattle | Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance | Signed 5 Oct 2026; in force 1 Sep 2027 | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
| Colorado | Proposed ban | Vetoed 2 Jun 2026 | Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026) |
Connecticut lets others use the practice if they disclose it with a statement such as “THIS PRICE WAS INCREASED USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA” Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026).
What is in New York State’s bill?
- Fines of up to $5,000 for a first violation and $20,000 for each later one, plus restitution WAMC (8 Jun 2026).
- Insurers are not covered. Banks can still check credit before offering loan terms.
- Loyalty discounts are allowed if customers enrol and discounts rest on past purchases only.
- Discounts for veterans, military personnel, educators and seniors are allowed if offered equally Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026).
- A companion ban on electronic shelf labels passed the Senate but did not get an Assembly vote WAMC (8 Jun 2026).
The Legislature passed the bill in June EPIC (4 Jun 2026). Governor Kathy Hochul has until the end of the year to sign or veto it.
How can you spot it?
- Compare logged in and logged out. Check the same item in a private window, signed out.
- Compare devices and places. The Target example turned on location. Try the app and the website, at home and away.
- Screenshot both prices. Note the time, the device and whether you were signed in.
- Limit the inputs. Turn off app location access and delete your advertising ID.
- Cut broker profiles. Brokers sell the profiles used for pricing. See our merged broker registries and California DROP guide.
A price gap alone is not proof. Prices also change with stock, time and promotions.
Where can you report it?
In New York City, the city can issue the fines. New York State’s bill and Maryland’s law are enforced by the attorney general Sidley Austin, Data Matters (27 Oct 2026).
Our guide on where to report lists consumer protection contacts.
Frequently asked questions
What is surveillance pricing?
Charging people different prices for the same thing based on their personal data, such as location, browsing or purchase history.
Is surveillance pricing illegal in New York?
New York City passed a ban on 12 November 2026. New York State’s One Fair Price Act passed in June and was awaiting the governor as of late October.
What is the fine under the NYC ban?
Up to $1,000 for each transaction that breaks the ban, according to Gothamist.
Which states ban surveillance pricing?
Maryland (food retail and delivery, in force 1 October 2026), Connecticut and New Jersey (from 2027). New York State’s bill awaits the governor.
Are loyalty discounts banned?
Generally no. New York State’s bill allows loyalty discounts based on past purchases if customers enrol. NYC’s sponsor said discounts are not affected.
How can I tell if I am being charged more?
Compare the price signed out, on another device and from another place, and keep screenshots. A gap alone is not proof.